Showing posts with label Taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Taxes. Show all posts

Monday, September 12, 2011

Comparing Federal Budget to a Household

The following letter to the editor appeared the San Antonio newspaper recently.  I think the letter-writer had a good point, but overlooked something, too.  Here's the letter, followed by my response:
"I want to provide some interesting information regarding the federal budget.
At the end of June, the government's income was $2.17 trillion. The budget was $3.82 trillion. New debt was $1.65 trillion. National debt was $14.27 trillion and recent budget cuts ($38.5 billion) totaled about 1 percent of the budget.

Now, let's take the above figures, cut off nine zeros and apply the results to a fictitious clan called the “Smith family.”

Total annual income of the Smith family is $21,700.

The amount of money the Smith family spent is $38,200.

The amount of new debt added to the Smiths' credit card is $16,500.

The outstanding balance on their credit card is now $142,710 and the amount they cut from the family budget was $385.

Do you know any family that would cut $385 from its budget in order to solve $16,500 in deficit spending? America's economic situation becomes more frightening with each passing day.

Harold Estep"
Here's my (unpublished) comment on Mr. Estep's letter:

Harold Estep's letter (The'Smith Family', 9/3/11) that puts the federal budget in terms of a family budget is helpful and apt. A family spending $38,200 a year while earning $21,700 DOES need to cut spending dramatically. But it would be stupid for the parents to say "it's unfair to ask us to work any harder: after all, we're bringing in $21,700, and the children aren't bringing home a thing! We can save a lot of money by dumping the kids and Grandma and moving to a tiny apartment."


We shouldn't expect the parents to suddenly start earning an extra $16,500 a year. But we also shouldn't assume that all $16,500 of their expenses are unnecessary. There's a middle ground somewhere: less spending AND more income. At the federal level, we need a committment to balancing the budget, not a committment to 'no new taxes.' Mr. Estep is right: we DO need major cuts in spending. But that's not the entire solution."

Saturday, July 30, 2011

Debt crisis: neither "side" reflects my views

The whole debt-limit crisis debate in Washington off target.  Clearly the debt-limit needs to be raised.  Going to a balanced budget cold-turkey without defaulting on our debts would require massive and immediate termination of tens of thousands of government jobs and/or reduction of payments to retirees and others currently receiving benefits.  Direct and indirect job losses would reduce tax receipts.  Reduced revenues would require further immediate reductions in government spending, and the economy would spiral downward at exactly the same time that the safety net disappeared. 

A significant portion of our economy is based on government spending.  I'm not saying this is a good thing.  But it is a fact.  Government spending directly supports large numbers of jobs.  Government benefit payments indirectly support an even larger number of jobs, because the money retirees receive gets spent, one way or another, and some of this spending supports jobs.

Republicans leaders know this.  They're not saying they won't raise the debt ceiling; they are only using the debt ceiling as leverage in their fight against government spending.  Even the balanced-budget amendment they propose would not go into effect until the fifth fiscal year after it is ratified.

There is no question that the Democrats also want to raise the debt ceiling.

So neither major party is saying the debt-ceiling shouldn't be raised.  But the country is facing a very real crisis because the debt-ceiling hasn't been raised.  The two parties are playing a game of chicken; each wants the other to back down in order to avoid a tragedy that would be far worse than either's plan.   And the public is being asked to choose sides. After all, the obvious way to avoid catastrophe is for one side or the other to win.  And if neither side can win, the next best thing for the nation, supposedly,  is a compromise. 

The press is racheting up the pressure on government leaders with stories warning the public about how the debt-ceiling impass could negatively affect citizens through higher interest rates and delayed or reduced benefits payments.

But the real story is how all this affects our nation's credit rating.  If our credit rating goes down we'll have a harder time borrowing money to fund our deficit and a harder time refinancing the $14 Trillion debt we've already incurred.  This 'harder time' will be reflected in higher interest rates for the government, which will increase the deficit even more.  And that's exactly what we don't need.

The Republicans are correct that we can't afford to keep spending at the same rate as we've been spending.  The Democrats are correct that we need to increase the debt-ceiling enough to get past the current crisis and not have the threat of the crisis returning in just a few months.  We've got to do something about the deficit, but risking the negative effects of not paying our bills is shooting ourselves in the foot.

But the Republican idea that low taxes are part of the solution to our deficit problem is ridiculous.  And yet the Democrats seem to have ceded this issue.   President Obama caved to this unreasonable position back in January when he agreed to extend the Bush tax cuts to everyone.  And neither the Democrats or the Republicans include any tax increases in their plans. 

Neither side has a reasonable position.  And the public is being encouraged to think selfishly about themselves, rather than our nation, when they consider the issue. 

I can't support any of these positions.  We need to raise the debt ceiling now.  We need to cut spending as soon as possible.  And we need to raise taxes so we can start down the road back to a budget surplus so we can get our debt down to a reasonable level.

Friday, July 22, 2011

'No more deficit!' more important than 'No new taxes'

I wrote the following to Eric Cantor and my (Republican) senators this evening.  (John Boehner's website was down; Congressman Cantor was my second choice.)  As you can see, I'm very concerned about the lack of progress on the debt-ceiling negotiations.  The clock is ticking, and as far as I can tell, the major obstacle is that Republicans are standing fast on their 'no tax increases' position.  Here's what I wrote:

"I'm a fiscal conservative, and I am upset that neither party is serious about eliminating the deficit. I had hopes for the Tea Party, but am disgusted when they proudly proclaim that the name of their party stands for Taxed Enough Already. We have a major, major debt problem which threatens to destroy our nation. We've had relatively low taxes for the past generation, and during that time out debt has soared from $1 Trillion to $14 Trillion. Why do you think that a 'no new taxes' pledge is more important than our nation's fiscal survival?

"Our nation had a huge debt after World War II, and our leaders addressed it by keeping the marginal tax rate for the highest income level at 90% for a generation. I'm not suggesting that rates should be raised that high again, but the fact that they were that high for much of my lifetime indicates that the claim that 'tax rates are already too high' is ridiculous.

"But I'm writing you from Texas because my concern is turning to anger at Republicans over the lack of a resolution to this debt-limit situation. Our nation cannot risk defaulting on its obligations. We owe $14 Triillion, as you know. Interest on this debt is immense and makes it very difficult to balance the budget, even with major spending cuts. It seems obvious to me that defaulting on our obligations is likely to raise the rates we have to pay on our debt, which will dramatically increase the deficit.

"We've dug ourselves a huge fiscal hole, and spending cuts alone will not get us out of it. The President doesn't have an 'obsession with raising taxes'; Republicans have a dangerous obsession with NOT raising taxes. End this budget stalement, and end it now! Compromise is in order."

Monday, July 11, 2011

The Cost of Prosperity

Low taxes brought us prosperity, but also a huge debt. It's prosperity we can no longer afford.

But monied interests, like well-heeled corporate drug pushers, see change as bad for business. They tell us "Low taxes aren't the problem! Low taxes are the solution. Here, have another hit, ..er.., dose. It will make you feel better." Don't listen to them, or you'll be gently lulled back to sleep, only to be awakened when they eliminate your job to protect the stock market that you thought was your friend.

To paraphrase Ecclesiastes: "There is a season for every purpose under heaven...a time to borrow from future generations, and a time to start paying back the debt." We've reached the time to start paying back what we've borrowed. It will be tough, but we can do it. We have to. We owe it to our children.